problems, which constructive feedback could you give or how could the problems be addressed?  Questions to Ask Yourself?  What is the problem? Is it a real or artificial problem?  How would you solve don’t fix immediately (destroys the flow)  Take annotated document and fix issues  #3 Ask Big Questions  Pitfall: Being overly focused on syntactic/local issues  Is the overall idea clearly communicated tools and techniques of the adversarial reviewer. SIGMOD Rec. 37(4) 2008] This paper leaves many questions unanswered. Some claims are questionable. The paper is of limited interest. 12 706.015 Introduction

Result Presentation  Reproducibility and RDM  Reminder: Paper Project Selection  Remaining Questions?

Outline, and Projects  Structure of Scientific Papers  Paper Project Proposals  Remaining Questions?  Next Lectures  02 Scientific Reading and Writing [Nov 04]  03 Experiments, Reproducibility